In my younger days I used to be scared to barter with folks. I always felt like I was too timid or shy, or maybe I was too Southern and didn’t want to offend anyone, or I didn’t feel like I could think on my feet fast enough to go back and forth with a vendor on prices. But then I got some practice while on vacation in other countries. When you go to a market in a lot of other countries, it’s kind of expected that the prices are going to be negotiated. One time we were in this Caribbean marketplace and this guy told me that he would make me a great deal on the trinket I was holding. He told me that he would sell me two for five dollars, or three for ten. It took me a second, but then my logical brain started working and I realized that wasn’t a good deal at all. It didn’t take me long to figure out that I was going to get a crappy deal if I bought three at $3.33 each instead of two at $2.50 each. This is when I started learning to haggle… and I haven’t stopped. These days it comes like a second nature to me. I don’t even hesitate to ask for a better deal. Let me share with you my three best secrets for getting a better deal in a bartering situation.
The first thing I do is ask for the price of the item, then I ask if that is the lowest price they can offer me. After they answer, I keep my mouth shut. I don’t say another word. I just give them a quizzical look and count to 15. Unless your vendor is an old man wearing overalls with a hay straw sticking out of his mouth, then I dare you to give this method a try and see what happens. If your vendor really IS an old man wearing overalls with a hay stray sticking out of his mouth, then be prepared to get into a very awkward, silent, quizzical, staring match. Those types are tough nuts to crack. But, for the most part, everyone who is out hocking their wares at a vendor booth is going to be ready to make a deal. So, ALLOW them make their deal. Fifteen seconds of not saying a word will typically make any vendor want to fill that uncomfortable silence and start slashing their prices. Give it a whirl sometime.
After they begin lowering the price, don’t take their first offer. Don’t take their second offer. Be prepared to walk, and never look interested in the item that you are trying to buy even if it makes you want to pee your pants with excitement. Stay calm and collected, and your bartering power will increase dramatically. If you can be silent and stare at them for a count of 15, then I promise that your bartering power will go up by leaps and bounds. Nobody enjoys uncomfortable silence, so shut up and let the vendor do the talking. See if the prices start to drop with every second that you sit and stare at them in silence. You might be very surprised at the ninja-like price slashing effectiveness of this one move.
Secondly, after I have found out the price of an item, I like to take my cell phone out and stare at it in deep concentration. The seller usually thinks that I’m looking it up on ebay to see what it’s really worth, but what I’m actually doing is calculating what my lowest price is going to be. If I have a LOT of stuff (like, multiple big-ticket items), I will add up the price of each item and then take at least 30% to 35% off of that number. That is my starting offer and I never expect to actually GET that amount. From there I will work my way up in small increments to see if they can do any better. Typically they will meet you in the middle and find a number that is agreeable to you both.
A word of warning: Once you start haggling, it is hard to stop. You’re going to want to haggle with everyone from the lady handing out samples at Costco to the Starbucks Barista over the price of your grande non-fat soy latte. Know when it’s appropriate to haggle. Hey, here’s a tip. Try it at Lowes or Home Depot sometime. You might be surprised.
There is an exception to my haggling rule at a vendor booth, and that applies to any item which proceeds are being donated to a great cause. For example, I chose to pay full price for this beautiful blue coat rack that I bought at The Chapel Market last year since all the proceeds from my sale benefited Acres of Hope and kids who needed adoptions. I loved it, and it looks perfect in Garrett’s rustic boys bathroom, so I feel good that I got a unique piece that I absolutely love while helping fund a charitable cause. It’s a win/win! If you know that the proceeds of an item are being donated to charity, don’t be the schmuck who tries to get a bargain on it.
~~~ Let me stop here and say that I’ve come back and edited this post after getting some comments about my advice on haggling with vendors. There is a time and a place to haggle, and you have to be the judge of when it’s appropriate. Here is a short guide for when I think it’s ok and when it’s not.
Yard sales and Flea Markets? Always haggle.
Junk or antique stores? Always ask if they are willing to come down in price. Usually they are.
Vendor booths with lots of found items or estate sale resales? It never hurts to ask. They put a lot of work into hauling and moving the stuff, but they are typically negotiable.
Vendor booths with handmade items like artwork, photography, pottery, glass, soaps, or sewn or knitted items? Tread lightly. These are artisans who have a skill that others don’t, and they deserve to be paid full price for their work. Plus they usually paid a hefty price just to rent the booth.
Vendor booths where all proceeds go to a charitable organization? Never ask for a discount. That’s just tacky.~~~
Let’s move ahead to the next point by clicking “next” or scroll back through if you just landed on this page from Pinterest.
That was one of the most entertaining posts to read on a Monday morning! I couldn’t wait to hit the next arrow to see what came of the little cat fight over the beehive. 🙂 It can get quite intense! We too played the haggling game in other countries. I can remember being in Cancun and the vendors would always wave us in with a “come see my store”. It sure was fun! Now, I have concrete tools to use to get the best price for what I truly love! And… it is good to know that I am not the only one who uses the word schmuck. Ha!
Wonderful and smart advice..any chance I can just shop with you 😉
I love this post! Great tips. I always run out of room in my car! LOL.
Great tips, Beth! I haven’t been to a good fair in a LONG time!
Thanks for sharing your words of wisdom with us! I love your stories, advice and especially the pictures!
What a lovely article full of great tips, Beth! 🙂 I truly appreciate a good buy! 🙂 I wanted to give your readers my two cents from the viewpoint of an artist who sells at art shows. I never mind when people ask if that is the lowest price I would take… ONCE. (Just like you said!!) 😉 I will tell them if it is indeed my lowest price- which it is 95% of the time… unless it is near break-down like you mentioned and I REALLY don’t want to take it home. But, what I don’t appreciate is the persistent asker. 😉 People don’t often consider the costs associated with creating my art. I have expenses for my materials, my electricity (YES, lots of electricity to run a kiln!), my insurance, my entry fees, my jury fees, my gas, and my TIME- not to mention 25+ years of experience! I am not selling things for Big-Lots prices (cheap store up north) because it is top-quality ART and I put my name on it! 🙂 I mean, if I can’t get my necessary fair price to make it worth my time to sell it, why would I bother? I will just keep the item in my stock and relist it in my Etsy shop! 😉
I love this! I am a huge fan of haggling and flea markets and all the rest. You are so right that it ends up making you want to haggle at unlikely places…but I have saved us money on brand new automotive parts, televisions, and other items, just because of the magic questions “is that your lowest price?” and “can you do better than XYZ competitor?”
Ah the sweet victory of scoring a deal!
Great photos and tips Beth!!
Great tips Beth! I have a hard time haggling with people – probably a lot because I have had my own booth and know what it’s like to try to make some money while at the same time selling things and making the customer happy too!
I’m so ready for the garage sale season here – I’m just itching to get out there and dig for treasure!
Great article! Yes, antiques dealers almost always have some wiggle room, but I have to throw in that us vendors who are selling as artists most often do not “haggle” at shows. Our items are handmade and priced so that we can make a fair wage, and many artists are already well underpriced. We love when shoppers value our work and understand that our prices are set to be fair to everyone. As Karan said before, I don’t mind if people ask (hey, you never know!) if that’s my “best price”, but I do expect that my first response is respected and hope that customers can find the value in having a one of a kind handmade piece. Can’t wait till the next Country Living Fair!
Beth — okay, I read this was a Southern accent and it was hilarious! I remember how scared you were before doing this event and how proud you were of yourself for meeting and BEATING your fears head-on. I was visiting an Atlanta friend when the 2012 CL fair was on and we had a blast, even without spending much money.
[…] Ford Tailgate Boys Bathroom DecorHow to Shop Like a Pro at Flea Markets and FestivalsHow to DIY a Giant Wooden Star from reclaimed wood. Stacked Galvanized Bucket […]
I enjoy reading a post that will make people think. Also, many thanks for allowing me to comment!
I love your style. You have made a very nice generic house a very interesting home.
I love to take something and make it my own with design on the cheap as well. I love putting things together and see what I can make for seasonal and holiday decor.
I couldn’t agree more! I am about to participate in my first craft fair. I crochet dress up hats and have an established etsy shop. My craft fair prices are already going to be lower than my etsy prices. It kind of made my stomach turn reading about taking 35% or more off the listed price as a haggling price. That is a bit offensive to me since it takes a lot of work to make handmade items. Also, keep in mind that vendors have to pay to be apart of such fairs.
I hear you loud and clear, Sarah! I have been meaning to get back to this post and edit it so it’s more reasonable. What do you think is a good place to start negotiating? Do you ever haggle with your customers? As a customer I typically will ask if that is someone’s best price on a piece (it’s the yard-saler in me, can’t help it). Do you think it depends on the type of vendor booth? If it’s a bunch of old junky furniture that I’ve seen sitting in the same booth all weekend I don’t mind asking off at all, but if it’s a handmade item I typically wouldn’t expect it to be discounted that much. I’m going to rework the post and I’d love to hear your feedback!
I love your blog and can’t wait until the 68 and 126 hwy yard sales through Kentucky
Thanks for a great post! Unfortunately now I feel bad for haggling for a better price at my local Habitat for Humanity Re-Store! (It was kitchen cabinets that had no shelves – they actually knocked off about 25%!)
[…] do you avoid overspending on useless junk, while also buying handmade goods wisely? This post by Beth at UnskinnyBoppy will […]
Hi every one, here every one is sharing such familiarity, thus it’s nice to read this webpage, and I used to visit this web site everyday.